Blog Details

70% Rule: Where the Other 30% Goes in House Flipping

It gives you a quick ceiling on what to pay for a flip, but it’s a filter for deciding whether a deal deserves a closer look, not a substitute for itemized underwriting. With gross flipping margins near their thinnest point since 2008, according to ATTOM’s 2025 report, the cushion this rule assumes is smaller than it used to be.


TL;DR:

  • For a $300,000 after repair value and $40,000 in repairs, the 70% calculation sets a maximum offer of $170,000 before further underwriting.
  • Use three to five recently sold comparable homes to estimate after repair value, then obtain contractor bids and add a 10% to 15% repair contingency.
  • Use about 65% when after repair value is below $150,000 or the market is slow; high value, fast moving properties may support 75% to 80%.
  • With gross ROI at 25.5%, selling costs near 10% of after repair value and holding and financing costs of 5% to 8% leave a 12% to 15% profit target.
  • Move to itemized underwriting for heavy renovations, long permit timelines, or unusual financing, because those costs can defeat a percentage based screen.

Decostabuyshomes
Explore Flexible Home Selling Options
DeCosta Buys Homes offers homeowners multiple selling solutions, including novation agreements and direct purchases of value-add residential properties.

Visit DeCosta Buys Homes

Table of Contents

Calculate Your Maximum Offer With a Worked Example

ARV is what the home will sell for once renovated, based on comparable sales. Subtract your repair estimate from that 70% figure, and you get your maximum allowable offer, or MAO.

Here’s the math in full, using the example from The Long Game’s breakdown of the formula: a home with a $300,000 ARV and $40,000 in needed repairs. Multiply $300,000 by 0.70 to get $210,000. Subtract the $40,000 repair estimate, and your MAO lands at $170,000. Pay more than that, and you’re squeezing your own margin before a single hammer swings.

Worked example of the 70 percent rule

The single biggest mistake flippers make is pairing an inflated ARV with an underestimated repair budget, according to practitioner analysis of the rule. Both errors push your “safe” offer higher than it actually is, and they tend to happen together because optimism about resale value often travels with optimism about renovation scope.

Run the calculation with this sequence:

  1. Pull ARV from sold comps, not listing prices.
  2. Walk the property and get a written repair estimate.
  3. Multiply ARV by 0.70.
  4. Subtract the repair estimate from that result.
  5. Compare the MAO to the seller’s asking price before you make an offer.

What the Other 30 Percent Actually Pays For

The breakdown has three buckets, and understanding the split tells you how much room you actually have for error.

  • Selling costs typically run close to 10% of ARV, covering agent commissions, closing fees, and buyer concessions.
  • Holding and financing costs usually eat another 5% to 8%, driven by loan points, interest, insurance, and utilities during the rehab period.
  • Profit is what’s left, often in the 12% to 15% range of ARV on a well-run deal, based on the typical breakdown described by The Long Game.

On a $300,000 ARV deal, that profit slice might start around $36,000 to $45,000. A repair overrun of $10,000 or an extra two months on the market can erase a third of that before you’ve noticed.

Pro Tip: Stress-test your repair estimate and your days-on-market assumption first. Those two variables move the most and erode profit fastest.

What the Other 30 Percent Actually Pays For — overview diagram

When 70% Is the Wrong Number for Your Deal

On a $500,000-plus ARV property, fixed costs are a smaller percentage of the total, so 72% to 75% can still leave a workable margin.

Market speed changes the math too. Fast-moving markets with multiple offers and short days on market reduce your holding-cost risk, which supports a slightly higher percentage. Slow markets, or properties needing permits and inspections, push holding time out and argue for a lower one.

Financing cost is the other lever. Hard-money loans with high points and double-digit interest rates increase your carry cost every month the renovation drags on, which is a factor AmeriSave’s guide to the rule flags as one of the fastest ways to turn a good screen into a bad outcome.

  • Tighten toward 65% when ARV is under $150,000 or the market is slow.
  • Relax toward 75% to 80% when ARV is high and the market moves fast.
  • Tighten further when hard-money interest is high or permits are expected.

Pro Tip: If your financing structure differs from a standard hard-money loan, the acceptable percentage shifts too. Alternative financing structures change the capital stack enough to move your safe MAO up or down.

Getting ARV and Repair Estimates Right Before You Trust the Number

A wrong ARV or a soft repair number produces a confident-looking MAO that’s wrong in either direction.

For ARV, pull three to five sold comps, not active listings, matching style and size, sold within the last three to six months. Document the comps the way an appraiser would, since you’ll likely need that same backup later if you refinance or resell. A full breakdown of how ARV is calculated and documented is worth reviewing before you lock in a number.

For repairs, walk the property systems-first: roof, HVAC, foundation, electrical, and plumbing before cosmetics.

  1. Collect three to five sold comps with sale dates and square footage.
  2. Walk the property and list every system issue separately from cosmetic ones.
  3. Get contractor bids for major trades.
  4. Add a 10% to 15% contingency to the total repair estimate.
  5. Keep photos, comps, and bids together as your documentation file.

Contractor bids and a month-by-month holding budget are what actually earn you the right to make an offer.*

Other Underwriting Rules Worth Knowing

The 70% rule isn’t the only screen available, and some deals fit other methods better.

  • Cost-plus underwriting adds purchase price, rehab cost, and a target profit dollar figure, which works well for major structural jobs or anything with a long permit timeline.
  • Profit-target underwriting sets a minimum dollar profit or percentage of ARV upfront, forcing you into a line-item budget before you can even calculate an offer.
  • Cash-on-cash screens matter most when leverage dominates your costs, since a highly financed deal can look fine on a percent-of-ARV basis while still delivering a weak return on your actual cash invested.

Use the percent screen for quick triage on straightforward deals. Once a property clears that first filter, or involves heavy renovation, long timelines, or unusual financing, move to a full line-item underwriting before you sign anything.

What the Latest Flipping Data Says About Your Margin

Recent numbers back up why a quick screen isn’t enough on its own. ATTOM’s 2025 year-end report found gross flipping ROI fell to 25.5%, the thinnest margin since 2008, with a median purchase price of $259,019 against a median flip price of $325,000. ATTOM’s Q3 2025 data showed that pressure continuing, with typical gross ROI dropping below 25% and wide variation across metro areas.

Metric 2025 figure
Median purchase price $259,019
Median flipped sale price $325,000
Typical gross ROI 25.5%

A gross ROI near 25% leaves far less room for error than the 30% buffer the 70% rule assumes, which is exactly why a repair overrun or a slow sale hits harder now than it did a decade ago.

How We Underwrite Beyond the Quick Screen

Before we finalize an offer, we use contractor bids, a line-item repair budget, and sourcing informed by direct-seller relationships and agent referrals across the markets we work in. That discipline is what lets us make offers we can actually stand behind.

— Travis

Get a Cash Offer While You Run Your Own Numbers

If you’d rather skip the spreadsheet entirely, we buy homes as-is, close in as little as 24 to 72 hours, and cover all closing costs with no agent commissions. It’s a useful comparison point while you’re running your own MAO on a fixer-upper you’re considering, whether you’re the seller trying to decide between fixing up and selling now, or an investor sizing up what a motivated seller might accept.

Decostabuyshomes

Get contractor bids, run your MAO, and request a cash offer to see how it stacks up before you commit to a renovation timeline.

FAQ

What is a good profit margin for flipping a house?

A profit slice of roughly 12% to 15% of ARV is a common target inside the 70% rule’s structure, based on the typical breakdown practitioner analysis describes. With gross ROI now closer to 25.5% nationally, margins that thin leave little room for repair overruns or extended holding time.

What is the hardest month to sell a house?

Seasonal slowdowns vary by local market, and no single national source in this article establishes one fixed month as universally hardest. Checking local days-on-market trends for your specific metro area is more reliable than relying on a general rule.

What is the 3-3-3 rule in real estate?

Definitions of this rule vary across sources, and it isn’t addressed by the data referenced in this article. If you’ve seen it applied to budgeting, timelines, or financing in flipping, confirm the specific definition with the source using it before relying on it.

Can I sell my house for $1 to a family member?

Selling a home for $1 raises tax and gift-reporting questions, since the IRS treats the difference between fair market value and the sale price as a potential gift. Review IRS Schedule C and related guidance on reporting and expense allocation, or speak with a tax professional, before structuring a sale this way.

Sources